I am gradually making my way through Shirley Jackson’s excellent, unsettling books and have previously read, loved, and reviewed We Have Always Lived in the Castle and The Haunting of Hill House on this blog. Next, I decided to foray into her short stories, and The Lottery and Other Stories perfectly fit the bill. As expected, it turned out to be a terrific collection. I read this book in October in the days leading up to Halloween but strangely forgot to put up a review at the time, hence the post now because it’s better late than never! What’s more, this is just the book to dip into during these cold, winter nights.
Shirley Jackson’s The Lottery and Other Stories is a brilliant, disquieting collection complete with her trademark sharp gaze on American suburbia, depicting how evil lurks in ordinary, everyday lives.
The titular story “The Lottery” is a menacing, suspenseful tale about the perils of herd thinking, blindly following archaic rituals, and how a seemingly idyllic setting can become a harbinger of violence. We are taken to a village where the tradition of conducting a lottery every year is unerringly followed. An event that sees the participation of all the inhabitants of the village, the process of conducting this lottery is explained in great detail, but the reader is not initially sure where this is headed. A few ominous signs heighten the atmosphere of unease – children diligently assembling stones in a spot, references to ancient myths and ceremonies, and the vehement protest of one character Tessie Hutchinson when her name is drawn – as the story hurtles towards its shocking conclusion.
In “The Daemon Lover”, we see a naïve bride desperately searching for her husband-to-be all over the city on their wedding day. To the reader, it’s obvious that the groom called James Harris has taken advantage of her blind trust and stood her up, but she’s not ready to accept that yet and embarks on an anxiety-inducing hunt for him throughout the neighbourhood. As she makes inquiries it is revealed that James Harris might not even be the groom’s real identity, it’s as if her phantom fiancé has vanished into thin air and snuffed out all her hopes of a happy married life. Even though the reader knows that this is not going to end happily, it’s the protagonist’s determined but futile quest that adds an element of tension but also sadness to the tale.
Another of my favourites “Charles” is a deliciously wicked tale of an impertinent child regaling his appalled parents of the antics of his classmate, the terrible brat Charles, whose consistently rude behaviour is enough to make parents quiver.
With the third week of kindergarten Charles was an institution in our family; the baby was being a Charles when she cried all afternoon; Laurie did a Charles when he filled his wagon full of mud and pulled it through the kitchen; even my husband, when he caught his elbow in the telephone cord and pulled telephone, ashtray, and a bowl of flowers off the table, said, after the first minute, “Looks like Charles.”
The haunting, beautifully written “Flower Garden” is an excellent piece depicting the darker undercurrents of racism and hypocrisy that underline the daily interactions of the American middle class, and how children are made to bear the burden of the adult world’s prejudices. We are introduced to the two Mrs Winnings (mother and daughter-in-law) who “had grown to look a good deal alike, as women will who live intimately together, and work in the same kitchen and get things done around the house in the same manner.” The Winnings are a respectable, well-to-do family in their locality, a joint family of sorts residing in a big house. At one point, the younger Mrs Winning harboured hopes of living in a quaint cottage in the neighborhood with her husband and children, but that dream failed to come to fruition, and now she is resigned to living in her husband’s family home.
Young Mrs. Winning had wanted, long ago, to buy the cottage herself, for her husband to make with his own hands into a home where they could live with their children, but now, accustomed as she was to the big old house at the top of the hill where her husband’s family had lived for generations, she had only a great kindness left toward the little cottage, and a wistful anxiety to see some happy young people living there. When she heard it was sold, as all the old houses were being sold in these days when no one could seem find a newer place live, she had allowed herself to watch daily for a sign that someone new was coming; every morning she glanced down from the back porch to see if there was smoke coming out of the cottage chimney, and every day going down the hill on her way to the store she hesitated past the cottage, watching carefully for the least movement within.
When the child Davey MacLane and his mother move into the cottage, Mrs Winnings is excited; she meets Mrs MacLane and is delighted with the latter’s tastes with respect to the interior décor and furnishings of the cottage. Gradually the two women become fast friends. But soon Mrs MacLane’s progressive and liberal ideals face resistance from a conservative community when she employs the young lad Billy Jones (half African American) to work in her garden. It’s a decision that sets the neighbourhood tongues wagging while also causing a rift in her friendship with Mrs Winnings.
The isolation and loneliness of single, independent women is superbly captured in “Elizabeth” where the titular character is employed in a small, struggling literary agency run by the fickle and feckless Robert Shax. When it comes to day-to-day operations, most of the heavy lifting is done by Elizabeth but she is often filled with hopelessness and despair at the smallness of their existence.
Because it was raining, and because she was depressed and out of sorts, and because Robbie had not come by quarter to one, Elizabeth treated herself to a Martini while she was waiting, sitting uncomfortably on a narrow chair in the restaurant, watching other unimpressive people go in and out. The restaurant was crowded, the floors wet from the feet coming in from the rain, and it was dark and dismal.
Elizabeth has big dreams and a burning ambition to transform the literary agency into a flourishing business, but those hopes are quickly dashed by Robert’s incompetency although she hasn’t entirely given up yet. Engaged in a tentative relationship with Robert, things worsen when Robert hires a good-looking, inexperienced secretary without consulting Elizabeth, and then Elizabeth herself decides to meet an old friend, ominously called Jim Harris…
We see subtle comedies play out in two boarding house stories, “Trial by Combat” and “Like Mother Used to Make.” In “Trial by Combat”, the young woman Emily Johnson finds small things occasionally missing from her furnished room, and she suspects Mrs Allen, a sixty-year-old woman, of these petty thefts, but Emily’s nuanced hints leaves the intractable Mrs Allen unruffled. In “Like Mother Used to Make” we meet David Turner, a meek young man, who is hurrying home to prepare an elaborate dinner for himself and his neighbour Marcia. Turner is proud of his comfortably furnished and decorated cubbyhole; a sharp contrast to Marcia’s messy and sparsely done-up apartment. However, when Marcia finally turns up at his door, she is not alone but has brought along an office colleague called Mr Harris (see a pattern here??), and when she artfully takes over the conversation calling David’s apartment her own, David is forced to play along in the charade.
Besides “Charles” and “Flower Garden”, children feature prominently in stories such as “Afternoon in Linen” and “After You, My Dear Alphonse” where we witness how the mysterious and opaque rules that make up their world are often at odds with the stifling boundaries of adult expectations.
Alienation and isolation, racism, the claustrophobia of societal beliefs, the dangers of customs and traditions, and the deceptively hidden horrors of urban communities are some of the central themes explored in this marvellous collection. We meet precocious children, lonely and wistful young women, phantom lovers, outcast widows, cruel neighbours, and rude, outspoken dummies, all of whom add a layer of richness to these delicious, psychologically astute stories.
In The Lottery and Other Stories, then, Jackson is at her best, exposing the horrors of suburban America while also displaying her flair for subtle wit and black humour. She reminds us that evil need not be epic in scope, that it is a powerful force even in the banality of everyday existence meticulously destroying lives and relationships. This suburban microcosm restricted both geographically and spiritually, where conservatism, herd mentality, and irrational prejudices gradually stifle otherness, individuality, and forward thinking can be as terrifying as the presence of spectral or supernatural elements, perhaps even more so.